Three Years, No DNA, Not Guilty: Jury Clears High School Student in CSC Trial
This case involved a 17-year-old client accused of CSC 3rd Degree under a physically helpless theory. The incident stemmed from a high school party in July 2020. The complainant alleged memory loss and claimed she must have been given something, but toxicology showed no alcohol or drugs other than her prescribed medications.
A SANE exam conducted hours later showed no injuries indicative of assault. DNA testing, performed using multiple methods, confirmed that our client was excluded from all samples tested.
The investigation raised concerns. Key witnesses—those who interacted with the complainant that night—were never interviewed. The lead detective cited other case priorities and acknowledged transcription errors in her reports.
Although our client’s DNA was excluded, and no physical evidence linked him to the allegations, prosecutors pursued trial based on circumstantial evidence, including partial Snapchat messages and a single recorded phone call.
At trial, testimony revealed inconsistencies in the complainant’s account and pointed to another individual whose DNA was found. We highlighted the gaps in the state’s investigation and the scientific certainty of our client’s exclusion.
The trial lasted one week. After several hours of deliberation, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty.
Client Reviews
★★★★★
Patrick Barone is the ONLY choice for DUI defense. He was realistic from the start and made it a point to look at my case before taking my money. As a business owner, when I think of attorneys, I think of the "shark infested waters. Patrick is a shark alright, but his prey is not the client; it's justice for his client. Ten stars Patrick!! Chris F.
★★★★★
Attorney Patrick Barone was very helpful and helped me understand the charge and sentence absolutely clearly. He also guided me through step by step helping me form a statement. His instructions were clear and detailed. It was obvious he cared about me understanding every important detail within my case. I would absolutely recommend this defense firm to anyone in need. Aaron B.
★★★★★
The Barone Defense Firm is the firm I recommend. They are truly concerned about the person, not just the legal issue, but the person as well. They are the most knowledgeable defense firm that I am aware of, having actually written the book on DWI Defense. If you are faced with a DWI you will not find a more professional and skilled law firm. But, most importantly, they care about how the accused individual recovers his or her life when the case is complete. Very remarkable group of lawyers. William H.