Super Lawyers
Justia Lawyer Rating
The Best Lawyers in America
Avvo Clients' Choice
Avvo Rating 10.0
National College for DUI Defense
National Collage for DUI Defense
American Council Of Second Amendment Lawyers
Avvo Clients Choice Award
Avvo Rating
Trial Lawyers University
Best Lawyers
James Publishing Author
Super Lawyers
Trial Lawyers College

People vs. M.W.

Court: Hopkins
Charge: OUIL

Hearing Officer Hopkins

The Arresting Officer in this case testified that he responded to the scene of a property damage accident. When he arrived, another Officer advised him that they were looking for the driver in the nearby field. The suspect was later found in the field, laying face down. When approached, he stood up with keys to "the truck" in his hand. A very strong odor of intoxicants was noted, along with red, watery and glassy eyes. He also admitted to drinking three or four beers.

Field sobriety tests were administered, including the horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN), walk-and-turn and one-leg stand. The suspect was unable to perform any of these to the satisfaction of the officer, and he was arrested for OUIL. He refused to submit to a breath test, and a warrant for blood was obtained. The Officer also testified that prior to asking the suspect to submit to the breath test, he read the Chemical Test Rights to the suspect from "the form", but did not further identify the form, other than to say it was "pink in color".

We argued that the Officer had failed to meet his burden of proof in that he had not established that the suspect was the driver of the vehicle (in legal jargon, that there was no "corpus delicti"), and therefore, that the arrest was unlawful. We also argued that the Officer had failed to meet his burden of proof relative to the Chemical Test Rights because he had not indicated specifically what the rights were, and because the "form" was not produced or properly identified, there was no evidence on the record that the implied consent statute had been satisfied.

The Hearing Officer issued a written opinion indicating that our appeal was granted. The opinion indicates "[A]s counsel for the petitioner noted at the hearing the form provided to the police to read the Chemical Test Rights from is not called a "DI177" as the officer testified to at this hearing. Without something in the record to establish with some specificity what Chemical Test Rights the officer advised the petitioner (sic) of I can not find that the petitioner was properly advised of the Chemical Test Rights request by statute".

Because the Petitioner's appeal was granted his operating privileges were not suspended for six months based on the alleged refusal to submit to a chemical test.

Call Today! FREE Consultation Lawyer and Receive Immediate Attention for Your Criminal Law Case Patrick T. Barone is a Michigan Super Lawyer, who has maintained continuous top attorney ratings since 2007. In addition, the Michigan native is the author of multiple books on OWI, DUI and criminal law. The OUIL attorney near me has lectured at over 80 legal seminars all over America. He leads Barone Defense Firm in providing aggressive legal warriors for each client's criminal case.

Contact us 24 hours a day at our law firm’s easy to remember toll-free number, 1-877-ALL-MICH or 877-255-6424, for a free criminal case review. The Michigan attorneys near me at Barone Defense Firm travel the entire Great Lakes State, to help citizens in legal trouble in Michigan for alleged criminal law violations.

For your FREE lawyer consultation, call today to learn how to protect yourself from a possible unwarranted conviction. What do you have to lose, when the free legal advice with our litigation team’s criminal lawyers near me can answer many tough questions?

Client Reviews
Patrick Barone is the ONLY choice for DUI defense. He was realistic from the start and made it a point to look at my case before taking my money. As a business owner, when I think of attorneys, I think of the "shark infested waters. Patrick is a shark alright, but his prey is not the client; it's justice for his client. Ten stars Patrick!! Chris F.
Attorney Patrick Barone was very helpful and helped me understand the charge and sentence absolutely clearly. He also guided me through step by step helping me form a statement. His instructions were clear and detailed. It was obvious he cared about me understanding every important detail within my case. I would absolutely recommend this defense firm to anyone in need. Aaron B.
The Barone Defense Firm is the firm I recommend. They are truly concerned about the person, not just the legal issue, but the person as well. They are the most knowledgeable defense firm that I am aware of, having actually written the book on DWI Defense. If you are faced with a DWI you will not find a more professional and skilled law firm. But, most importantly, they care about how the accused individual recovers his or her life when the case is complete. Very remarkable group of lawyers. William H.